Yeah, I'm a fan of the original trilogy. Not quite a fanboy, my fanboy tendencies lie in other franchises...
The second trilogy has it's moments, but I hated Episode III (that's 2+ hours of my life I'm not getting back). I kept hoping throughout the viewing that the writers might do something interesting, but no it was just a long slow grind. It didn't help that you already knew that Anikan would become Darth Vader. Felt more like a poorly written prelude/backstory thing than an actual movie. Sure, the special effects were cool, and it cost a bjillion dollars to make, but yeah, I was not amused at the end of that movie...
I very much enjoyed Episode I though. Even though they did kill off one of the most awesome characters ever (Qui Gonn Jinn)!
I'm still on the fence about episode 7. JJ Abrams didn't do Star Trek any favors (another 2+ hours of my life I'm not getting back). I still do not have faith in his ability to do Episode 7 right, but he could of course prove his skeptics wrong...