Choosing between 2009 and 2010, all things equal, would go with 2010. Considering a 400 round trip to get the 2010, would go with a 2009. But, I buy bikes that have not been messed with mechanically or electronically so I would not get this 2009. I would put the safety back on, wait and keep looking.
Think both bikes are overpriced. I am considering a 2011, 1,600 miles, pristine, purchased off the showroom floor 12 months ago, no extras, $10,600. Saw a 4 sale post on one forum, 2012 for $10,000, has 400 miles on it and TechSpec tank protectors! So I have you my answer on years and my answer on price.