That is way off base, and the motorcycle magazines seem to have a different opinion. The C14 and the FJR have everything that 3/4 of riders want/need and are satisfied with. The BMW adds a bunch of fancy add ons and luxury items, which is really no different then a high end car. Then you add in reliability between the brands, cost of ownership, and finally dealer support and locations.......then you are right in it not even being close. Like I said before, I will be getting away from the big heavy bikes sooner than later, I did more than fine traveling the country on a Vstrom 1000.......and went places the C14 could not.
All due respect, where are you coming from with this? Most if not all of the magazines acknowledge the K16 is the superior bike if in fact you use magazine articles as the litmus. The only debate generally has been how resoundingly the editors chose the K16 over the C14, and how to compare the value proposition of the two.
Does my C14 have better relaibility than my K16? So far it's no better or worse, time will tell and neither of us can drill down deep enough into fact to make a real declaration. Maybe cost of ownership is higher on the K16. Has nothing to do with the capabilities of the K16 and the fact that it truly is the superior bike. Smoother, more torque, better roll on acceleration, better wind protection, better two up bike, heated seat, cruise, ESA, integrated GPS/bluetooth/com, better lighting, more range, better brakes.
I find your comment about 3/4 of ST riders being satisfied without "a bunch of fancy add ons and luxury items" highly contradictory. That is completely false as evidenced by the countless members here who add cruise, heated seat, nav, countless ergonomical farkles to make the C14 more long distance friendly, etc. Myself included.
I have owned both, and I could never look anyone in the eye and tell them my C14 is superior to the K16. The only thing my C14 does better is to your point, provide me with better dealer support, lower initial cost and cost to maintain. I don't dimiss these virtues at all, and from a value perspective the C14 is fast, refined, and a great bike.
Please point me toward the magazine articles (plural as you claim) that contradict my opinion. I thought I read or viewed just about every comparison that was done before I bought the K16 and since.
K16 is the better bike categorically, and should be for the cost differential.