My thoughts are instead of asking if we like our seats, you should be inquiring about the seating position and the seating position you are looking for.
I sat on a friends bike with the corbin seat and felt like I was sitting on one of my cruisers. The seat made me want to sit straight up which meant the handlebars needed to be about 6 inches further back to be comfortable. Otherwise I would be leaning my back forward.
I have a Ninja 1400 seat which is great for around town because you can put your feet down easily, move around on the seat in the curves, but not so great for long distance.
I have a Sargent regular height with pod. That seat still keeps me in the sport touring riding position and do not feel the need for risers on the bars. I have done 400 mile days with only slight soreness towards the end of the day, but a quick recovery.
Good luck with your choices. Another option would be to find a local custom seat maker and get one made to your specifications. I did that with my Versys. Created a seat I can ride on all day long and got rid of the hump that creates the passenger seat so I can move around.