Sorry to say Jim, but rightly or wrongly is determined by what works and what does not work. The spring is supposed to be there because some dummy in the engineering department thought it would be a good idea. Had he ridden the bike both with and without the spring he would have realized that it is detrimental and downright dangerous. I'm speaking specifically of the '09 model with ABS as this is the only one I have owned and ridden. I cannot refer to the later models with linked brakes as I have not ridden one or even looked at one to see if the offending spring is there. Anyone owning and '08 or '09 who questions my advice can ignore it and post no comments as to its veracity or they can spend the ten minutes or so that it takes to remove the spring, ride it and make an empirical determination. After putting my advice to the test, whether you agree or disagree, you are then fully qualified to post a comment. As for your blind trust in the wisdom of engineers who design our various modes of transportation. I have done all of the maintenance, modifications, fabrication of improvements, etc. on all of my vehicles, two wheels or four and the vehicles of others for the past 55 years. In that time I have been amazed many times over that some of the engineering feats displayed in the end product are excellent while coexisting on the same vehicle with something that was designed by an idiot, yet there it is right next to the work of a genius.
While I agree with some of your statements, the OP has a 'new' bike. I put that in quotes because it's an 09 that's been sitting on the dealership floor for quite some time. We all know what happens to bikes that sit for a long time. This could be a safety issue or it's working as designed. We don't know because we aren't the ones riding it. What we perceive as 'normal' may not be perceived as normal to the OP. Again, we don't know cause we're sitting behind a PC making armchair suggestions. He has a warranty. He should use it to check this out. If he should want to try the spring removal to 'improve' his brakes then more power to him and good luck all around. He can always put it back.
I'm extremely lucky with my bike as I've ridden with that spring connected since early August of 07 without serious injury, perceived decreased braking performance, or causing me to nearly tip over in low speed maneuvers. I'm keeping mine on.
We thank you sincerely for bringing that to our attention again and do hope you bring more insight and new ideas to our forum. We really appreciate new forum members adding to our knowledge base.